FTA / APSA Monthly Shipping Report - March 2024

Monday, March 25, 2024



Freight & Trade Alliance (FTA) and the Australian Peak Shippers Association (APSA) have prepared the following report using practical efforts to ensure that the commentaries are accurate, generally using source intelligence and publicly available data. 

MARCH 2024 - SNAPSHOT

  • Rates
    • Drewry's composite World Container Index (WCI) has decreased steadily in the past 8 consecutive weeks to $3,010.00 per 40ft container as at 21 March 2024. A 24% decline since reaching a high of  $3,964.00 per 40ft container at 25 January 2024 after 8 previous consecutive weekly gains.
    • Rate levels are up 71% when compared with the same period last year.
    • The average composite index for the year-to-date is $3,453 per 40ft container, which is $752 higher than the 10-year average rate of $2,701 (which was inflated by the exceptional 2020-22 Covid period).

ANL announce they will implement a rate restoration program from 15th April 2024, from NEA to AUEC, at USD250 per 20' dry/reefer & USD500 per 40' dry/reefer for all shipment from North East Asia to Australia East Coast.

  • Purchasing Manager's Index (PMI)
    • In January, the manufacturing output Purchasing Managers' Index (PMI) improved to 50.3, surpassing the 50 mark for the first time in eight months indicating expansion. The PMI for new export orders rose to 48.8, yet it still falls short of the crucial 50 mark, indicating that while the decline in worldwide exports is slowing, it persists.

                         
 

  • Shipping Line Financial Results
    • In the fiscal year 2023, the shipping industry experienced a significant decline in revenue, with reductions ranging from 46.6% to 62.6% compared to the previous year. The downturn is viewed as a correction from the abnormal growth rates of the 2021-2022 Covid affected period, aligning with the more stable growth seen in 2018-2019, rather than a fundamental loss in revenue.
    • Profitability also took a hit, with ZIMYang Ming, and Wan Hai reporting EBIT losses. Although four shipping lines managed EBITs exceeding USD$1bn, these figures fell short of the extraordinary profits witnessed during the 2021-2022 period. Profitability, as measured by EBIT per TEU, varied significantly among companies.
        • EBIT/TEU performance for 2023:
          • Maersk recorded a lower EBIT/TEU of USD$94, yet it surpassed most pre-pandemic figures. Maersk CEO Vincent Clerc also announced at the annual shareholders meeting that the global container shipping market is facing overcapacity, driving rates to unsustainable levels, which, along with a significant addition of new ships, is expected to impact profits negatively.
          • Hapag-Lloyd's EBIT/TEU of USD$235 was the highest outside of the pandemic years.
          • ONE's EBIT/TEU stood at USD$116, without a pre-pandemic comparison.
          • HMM's EBIT/TEU of USD$119 was above its performance from 2011 to 2019, despite being lower than in 2020.
          • ZIM faced a significant loss, with an EBIT/TEU of -USD$765, largely due to a 'non-cash impairment' loss of USD$2.06bn recorded in Q3.


                

  • Panama Canal
    • The Panama Canal Authority (ACP), in response to current and projected levels of Gatun Lake, in March announced that it will increase the number of daily slots available, bringing the number of daily transits up from 24 to 27 per day effective March 25.
    • The ACP is anticipating that transit levels through the canal will return to 'normal' by September, as rains return to the region. Speaking at this year's CMA Shipping conference, the ACP deputy administrator said that the hope is when the rainy season starts in late April to early May, the process of gradually increasing transits further will begin. The deputy administrator quoted "We won't go back to the 36-38 [transits], but we definitely are hoping to go at least 34 by the end of May".
    • Contingency planning is underway to avoid a repeat of the issues in future, with a proposal (subject to government approval) of an additional lake by constructing a new dam to channel water through the canal so water levels can be maintained. A new lake will allow the locks to add between 11 and 15 passings each day, elevating daily transits to a maximum of around 50. 
  • Red Sea
    • Carriers continue to avoid the Red Sea due to the ongoing disruptions with, at time of publication, the carriers of the three main shipping alliances still not currently sailing through the troubled areas. 
    • Houthi rebels continue attacks on vessels transiting the Red Sea. In the latest attack on 23rd March, rebels fired anti-ship missiles at the Chinese-flagged ship M/V Huang Pu. This despite news reports suggesting that earlier that week, both China and Russia received direct assurances from the Houthi's chief negotiator Mohammed Abdulsalam that their ships would pass safely through the Red Sea. An estimated US$160 billion of Chinese exports flows through the the Red Sea each year. 
    • The Rubymar cargo ship, which was attacked last month, is the first vessel sunk since Houthi militants began targeting commercial shipping in November. A Yemeni government statement said the ship had sunk on 1st March and warned of an "environmental catastrophe", with the local fishing industry, some of the world's largest coral reefs and desalination plants supplying millions with drinking water all at risk from the large amounts of fertiliser and oil spilled into the Red Sea.
    • J.P. Morgan research suggests this situation has contributed to higher global inflation, estimating that the disruptions could add up to 0.7% to global core goods inflation and 0.3% to overall core inflation in the first half of 2024.
    • War-risk insurance premiums have seen a 900% rise from below a level of 0.1% of the value of a vessel during the final weeks of last year, to as much as 1% of vessel value by the start of February. 

          
  

  • Haiti
  • As a result of civil unrest and gang violence, carriers have suspended services and/or stopped accepting bookings to and from Haiti capital Port-au-Prince. CMA CGM were the latest to suspend services in mid-March, following ZIM, Maersk, and Hapag-Lloyd in announcing suspension of services. The country has been plagued by rampant gang violence since January, forcing a shutdown of the country's main airport and plunging the nation further into chaos.

  • Shipping Competition
    • The Alliance : Ocean Network Express (ONE) has hinted at an upcoming April announcement that could clarify its position and future direction within the industry since the decision of Hapag-Lloyd to exit The Alliance and link with Maersk via the Gemini Cooperation. Managing Director Louis Tang indicated that while options are still being explored, ONE aims to reassure customers of improved service quality starting next February. With the container shipping landscape rapidly evolving, particularly with the Gemini Cooperation and the strengthened Ocean Alliance setting new precedents, the focus is now on how ONE and other members of The Alliance (HMM & Yang Ming) will adapt, amidst discussions of potential collaborations and niche service offerings to maintain competitiveness.
    • Container Shipping Alliance Landscape
      • The world's leading shipping firms are divided into three principal alliances:
        1. 2M: Comprising MSC and Maersk (to be dissolved starting January 2025).
        2. Ocean Alliance: Includes Cosco, CMA CGM, Evergreen, and OOCL.
        3. THE Alliance: Consists of Hapag-Lloyd, ONE, HMM, and Yang Ming. (Hapag-Lloyd leaving end January 2025).
      • Looking ahead to next year:
        1. MSC: Will be operating independently.
        2. Gemini Cooperation: A new collaboration between Maersk and Hapag-Lloyd, beginning February 2025.
        3. Ocean Alliance: Consists of Cosco, CMA CGM, Evergreen, and OOCL, with a recent extension through 2032.
        4. THE Alliance: Continues to include ONE, HMM, and Yang Ming.

 

  • Mergers/Acquisitions
    • HMM - After the collapsed deal with Harim Group in February, the South Korean government Minister of Oceans and Fisheries says that there are "no plans for the resale of HMM" and that the state owners will instead focus on making plans "with the principle of enabling it to be operated soundly".
    • DB Schenker - the sale is back in the spotlight with Kuehne+Nagel & DHL both announcing in February and March respectively that they would not be making a bid, Maersk has suggesting they are indeed looking into it the acquisition as a possible fit for their business. Maersk have since hired advisors to help look into a possible bid. DSV are the other main contender touted as a possible fit. If the German logistics group is bought by either DSV or Maersk, it would be the largest acquisition in Danish history. DB Schenker while sharing their 2023 FY results, mentioned that more than 20 parties had registered an interest in purchasing the forwarder.

 

  • Schedule Reliability
    • Global schedule reliability has declined to 51.6%. It decreased by 5.1% month-on-month in January 2024 with the downward trend continuing at the same rate as the month prior. On a year-on-year basis, schedule reliability was 0.8% lower than the previous year. 
    • Due to the continuation of sailings around the Cape of Good Hope, the average delay for LATE vessel arrivals deteriorated once again, increasing by 0.59 days month-on-month up to 6.01 days.
    • CMA CGM was the most reliable top-13 carrier in January 2024 with schedule reliability of 54.7%, with only another four carriers that were above the 50% mark.

               

 

  • Cancellations
    • Between week 13 (25 Mar-31 Mar) and week 17 (22 Apr-28 Apr), 41 cancelled sailings have been announced out of a total of 650 scheduled sailings, representing a 6% cancellation rate. During this period, 51% of the blank sailings will occur on the Transpacific Eastbound, 27% on the Asia-North Europe and Med, and 22% on Transatlantic Westbound trade.
    • In the Australian market, while January and February saw cancellation rates of 19% and 12.66% respectively on China to Australia trade, it has since reduced down to 6.25% based on March schedule data, with only 6 of 96 scheduled sailings cancelled. 
    • OCEAN Alliance have announced 12.5 cancellations, followed by THE Alliance and 2M with 7.5 and 2 cancellations, respectively. During the same period, 19 blank sailings have been implemented by non-Alliance services.

          

  • Orderbook / Scrapping
    • Bimco suggests that by 2025, the average size of container ships is expected to exceed 5,000 TEU, highlighting the maritime industry's shift towards larger, more efficient vessels. Since 2006, the average vessel size has doubled to 4,580 TEU, driven by the prevalence of ships over 12,000 TEU, which now make up 51% of fleet capacity expansion. These larger ships have transformed container shipping economics and environmental impact, offering 25% cost and emissions savings per TEU compared to smaller ships. This trend towards bigger vessels reflects the industry's push for greater efficiency and sustainability.
    • Ship deliveries will hit a new record high in 2024,  beating the record set in 2023. The fleet is expected to grow 14.9% between end 2023 and end 2025.
    • MSC still lead the way in the ordering stakes, with 111 vessels still on order which equates to 23.1% of their existing fleet :




  • Supply / Demand
    • The ship supply/demand balance which is expected to see overcapacity impact the market until 2027, is anticipated to improve in 2024 due to Houthi attacks in the Red Sea. This situation is expected to continue to affect the market in the first half of 2024, with ship routings likely reverting to the usual Suez Canal path thereafter (subject to geopolitical tensions easing). Since this increased demand for ships is not tied to cargo volume growth, it's expected that ship demand will decline again in 2025.

              
 

  • Innovation
    • Pan Ocean is launching South Korea's first autonomous containership, the POS Singapore, for its service linking South Korea with Thailand and Vietnam. This move, part of a project selected by the Ministry of Oceans and Fisheries in 2022, showcases a significant advancement in maritime transport with the use of artificial intelligence and big data. The POS Singapore, set to start operations on April 6, represents a pioneering effort in sustainable and innovative shipping, aiming to enhance efficiency and reduce human error on major trade routes. This initiative marks a significant milestone in the development and deployment of autonomous shipping technologies.

 

  • Legal
    • Volkswagen Group faces a lawsuit, with allegations focusing on a lithium-ion battery from a Porsche EV as the cause In the devastating fire on board the Felicity Ace in February 2022. The vessel which was transporting 3965 luxury vehicles including Porsche EVs from Germany to the US, resulted in losses estimated at AUD$236 million. Allegations accuse the company of not adequately disclosing the risks associated with transporting electric vehicles.

           

  • Sustainability
    • The Singapore and Australian governments earlier in March signed an memorandum of understanding (MOU) to establish a green and digital shipping corridor. The Australian government stating the collaboration aimed to leverage Australia's potential as a major producer of green fuels and Singapore's status as the world's top bunkering hub and transhipment port to advance decarbonisation of the maritime industry. Under the MOU, both countries will work with interested partners to explore opportunities to develop zero or near-zero emission fuel supply chains, including building infrastructure, formalising standards, and developing and implementing the training requirements.
    • IMO's Marine Environment Protection Committee (MEPC 81) met in London 18-22 March, where there was significant momentum toward adopting a greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions levy in the maritime industry. The Clean Shipping Coalition lauded the growing consensus for a GHG emissions levy, emphasising its importance over less impactful alternatives, while also stressing the need to focus on other vital measures like the global fuel standard (GFS) and enhancing energy efficiency through the Carbon Intensity Indicator (CII). A key proposal from the Pacific Islands and Belize set a notable price point of USD$150 per tonne of GHG emissions, marking an ambitious step towards meaningful climate action in shipping. The committee urged governments to work constructively over the (northern) summer to ensure it prioritises equity and a just transition for all involved. The meetings signal a critical move towards implementing comprehensive strategies to reduce the shipping sector's carbon footprint and achieve global GHG reduction targets.
    • British Airways owner the IAG has announced its biggest-ever deal to purchase sustainable aviation fuel (SAF) from a US-based producer. Under a fourteen-year contract, California-based Twelve will supply the IAG with 785,000 tonnes of e-SAF to support its five European airlines – British Airways, Iberia, Aer Lingus, Vueling and Level. IAG has committed to 10 per cent SAF use by 2030 and said the deal takes the supply needed to one-third of the target.

 

·         Terminal and Port Update 

o    Patrick terminals

§  Brisbane: Delays approx. 0.5 day 

§  Fremantle: Delays approx. 0.5 day

§  Sydney: Delays approx. 3-4 days

§  Melbourne: Delays approx. 0.5 day

§  A reminder that Patrick TAC charges increased effective 4 March 2024.

o    DP World Terminals

§  Brisbane: Working with delays approx. 3 days - Brisbane terminal still experiencing considerable delays to truck turnaround times reported to be anywhere between 2 to 3 hours. 

§  Fremantle: Delays approx. 0.5 day

§  Sydney: Delays approx. 0.5 day

§  Melbourne: Delays approx. 1 day

o    VICT

§  Melbourne: Delays approx. 1.5 day

·          

o    AAT

§  Brisbane: Congestion issues expected until late March, which is a flow on effect from previous congestion in MEL (Mirrat terminal).

§  Port Kembla: Working with minimal delays.

§  Melbourne: Working with minimal delays.

o    MIRRAT

§  Melbourne: Congestion has subsided, with berthing delays now just 3 days.

o    New Zealand 

§  Auckland: delays approx. 1 day

§  Tauranga: minimal delays approx. 0.5 day

§  Napier: minimal delays approx. 0.5 day

§  Lyttleton: minimal delays approx. 0.5 day

 

  • Equipment
    • Delays of dehiring empty containers expected to continue throughout March and into April.
    • Melbourne requires increased lead times due to major infrastructure road works as transport companies deal with delays in and around the port precinct.  

 

  • Enterprise Agreements -
    • DP World (Australia) and the Maritime Union of Australia (MUA) are still yet to finalise the in-principle agreement reached on 2nd February. Part B negotiations are still ongoing.
    • DP World (Brisbane) are still yet to reach an agreement with the Electrical Trades Union (ETU). 
    • DP World (Fremantle) announced that the MUA will hold a stop work meeting on Thursday 28th March from 1200-1600.
    • VICT are the next of the major terminals fast approaching the end of their current enterprise agreement, with negotiations expected to commence in October 2024 :

 

  • Global Air Freight  
    • Latest market data shows rates have steadied at an average USD$2.37 per kg, 4.4% higher than the same period in February. The latest average spot rate continued to show a double-digit year-over-year decline of 11.6%.
    • IATA released data for January 2024 global air cargo markets indicating a strong start to 2024.
      • Total demand, increased by 18.4% compared to January 2023 levels (19.8% for international operations). This significant upturn marks the highest annual growth since 2021.
      • Capacity, was up 14.6% compared to January 2023 (18.2% for international operations). This was largely related to the growth in belly capacity. International belly capacity rose 25.8% year-on-year on the strength of passenger markets.
    • Vietjet announce a new service between Melbourne and Hanoi to commence on 3-4 June. The route will operate from Hanoi every Monday and Friday using Vietjet's A330 fleet, returning from Melbourne on Tuesdays and Saturdays. The service complements Vietjet's existing flights between Melbourne and Ho Chi Minh City.
    • WorldACD data shows available capacity in the Asia Pacific region is up +19% year-on-year, with chargeable weight also improving by +10% in comparison to last year : 

 


TRADE DATA UPDATES
 

 


AUSTRALIAN PART X SHIPPING NOTICES

APSA is the designated peak shipper body granted status by the Federal Minister for Infrastructure and Transport under Part X of the Consumer & Competition Act to represent the interests of Australian shippers generally in relation to liner cargo shipping services. Notices have been received and are available for members' reference HERE 
(FTA / APSA LOGIN REQUIRED)
 


FTA / APSA IN THE MEDIA

18 MARCH 2024 : DCN - A catalyst for Australian shipping competition reform
11 MARCH 2024 : The Australian - The real cost of super fund monopolies from sky to sea
 
Tom Jensen - Head of International Freight & Logistics - FTA / APSA

Copyright © 2024 Freight & Trade Alliance (FTA) Pty Ltd, All rights reserved